Some Big Pharma investors wanted to know whether drug prices are rising because executives personally benefit from the hikes. But when they put that question up for a vote, their fellow shareholders turned them away.
In a series of annual meetings at top drugmakers, shareholders rejected calls for more information on executive compensation—namely, whether price hikes directly fueled increases in C-suite pay.
Faith-based investor group ICCR had submitted proposals to AbbVie, Celgene, Johnson & Johnson, Merck & Co., Pfizer and Vertex requesting information about how price hikes feed sales goals and other exec pay metrics. It was the second straight year ICCR had done so—and again, the larger group of shareholders rejected the idea.
AbbVie, J&J, Pfizer and Merck shareholders turned away the proposals, an ICCR representative said via email; support ranged from 22% to 29%. Vertex shareholders are set to vote on the proposal June 5.
The shareholder resolutions asked drugmakers whether they use price hikes to meet sales goals, whether boards must approve price hikes, and how compensation committees use revenue goals to determine incentive pay.
ICCR has said that the companies’ routine price hikes pose long-term regulatory and reputational risks, and the group has posed the question as to whether incentive pay goals actually encourage executives to raise prices.
In 2018, AbbVie paid its CEO Richard Gonzalez $21 million, while Celgene’s CEO Mark Alles made $16.2 million. Pfizer’s former CEO Ian Read pulled in $19.5 million in compensation; J&J’s Alex Gorsky scored $20 million; and Merck’s Ken Frazier earned $20.9 million. Vertex CEO Jeffrey Leiden snagged a pay raise to $18.8 million.
Last year, the proposals won between 21% and 28% of shareholder support.
Ahead of the vote, a Pfizer spokeswoman said the company "does not believe this proposal is in the best interests of the company or shareholders."
"The executive compensation program is aligned with both short-term performance and long-term performance and shareholder value measures that encourage thoughtful pricing actions," she said last month.
ICCR’s member groups started the campaign in response to a Credit Suisse report that concluded many pharma companies derived all of their earnings growth in 2016 from price hikes.
Editor's note: This story was updated to reflect that Vertex shareholders haven't voted on the proposal. The company's annual meeting is June 5.