It's another fail for AstraZeneca's I-O combo, but it may not mean what you think

Investors shouldn't read too much into Imfinzi and tremelimumab's failure in third-line lung cancer, analyst Tim Anderson contends. (AstraZeneca)

AstraZeneca has come up short in another lung cancer trial of its immuno-oncology combo, this time in patients who've failed on two prior treatments.

But investors shouldn’t use the outcome to predict the forthcoming results of a closely watched first-line study, analysts say.

Tuesday, the British drugmaker said its PD-L1 med Imfinzi and candidate tremelimumab had failed to improve survival in third-line patients whose tumors didn’t express PD-L1. There was a bright spot, though: A substudy that pitted solo Imfinzi against chemo in PD-L1-positive patients showed a “clinically meaningful” difference for the AZ drug in the risk of death.

Free Webinar

Striving for Zero in Quality & Manufacturing

Pharmaceutical and medical device manufacturers strive towards a culture of zero – zero hazards, zero defects, and zero waste. This webinar will discuss the role that content management plays in pharmaceutical manufacturing to help companies reach the goal of zero in Quality and Manufacturing.

The results weren’t terribly surprising to analysts; Bernstein’s Tim Anderson, for one, said in a note to clients that he thought the trial, dubbed Arctic, “was likely to yield mixed results (and it did).”

And the way he sees it, that’s not such a bad thing. Overall, “the field has moved on,” he said, calling Arctic “basically the hangover from a now abandoned hypothesis” that PD-L1/CTLA4 pairings such as AZ’s will extend benefits to the PD-L1 negative population.

ODDO BHF’s Pierre Corby wrote in his own note to clients that removing the combination from models would have “minimum impact.”

RELATED: AstraZeneca's Mystic shortfall is an immuno-oncology shake-up for Bristol-Myers and a bolster for Merck and Roche

And while investors may be tempted to take the outcome as a sign that the Imfinzi-tremelimumab combo is destined for failure in first-line, PD-L1-positive patients—the all-important population in the I-O market—they shouldn’t, Anderson said.

“That outcome is certainly not foreshadowed” by the miss in PD-L1 negative patients, he wrote.

If there’s any readthrough to Mystic, AstraZeneca’s first-line trial, it’s that Imfinzi still holds promise as a monotherapy, Anderson figures.

“We continue to believe that Imfinzi is likely is show an OS benefit in 1L PD-L1(+) patients, and obtain a (modest) foothold in the market,” he wrote.

RELATED: 2018 is here. Now get ready for ‘market-defining’ I-O readouts

Of course, it’ll still be a while before industry watchers have that data, which is slated to arrive in the second half of the year. And in the meantime, there will be plenty of other key I-O news from companies including Merck and Roche that should keep investors busy.

Suggested Articles

The cleaning procedures are so poor at a Zydus Cadila plant in India that the FDA says a sampling found 10 different cross-contaminated products.

Oklahoma politicians contend J&J should be on the line for future abatement costs even after a $572 million verdict, but J&J sees things differently.

Abbott helmsman Miles White, who oversaw the spinoffs of AbbVie and Hospira, will step down as CEO after 21 years at the top job.