Quality over quantity: Healthcare messages not tuned into patient needs, survey finds

Email Marketing
Lirio probed 1,500 U.S. adults on how healthcare organizations communicate with them, uncovering a "fundamental disconnect." (Africa Studio for Shutterstock)

Gone are the days in which healthcare communications solely come from the physician office’s landline. Today, healthcare systems have more ways than ever to contact patients, from patient portals to text and email notifications and more. Yet these communications often fall short of the personalization that makes a patient listen in. 

Behavior science and AI-powered behavioral intelligence platform Lirio commissioned a recent survey of 1,500 U.S. adults to explore how healthcare organizations communicate with their patients, uncovering what Lirio calls a “fundamental disconnect" in a new report.  

As it turns out, while patients report receiving a “substantial amount” of healthcare communications, those communications miss the mark in reflecting the individual needs, circumstances or preferences of most respondents. Specifically, 58% of those surveyed indicated that healthcare communications “don’t consistently feel relevant” to their needs, according to Lirio. 

To put the findings in context, Lirio points out that health systems are on the cusp of the highest-volume outreach period of the year, with open enrollment, flu season and year-end care gap closures piling on top of each other. The typical response to patient disengagement, Lirio explains, is to stack the mountain of alerts even higher with automated texts, app notifications and calls. 

But content that feels irrelevant or too generic risks being ignored, as nearly one in four (24.4%) respondents pointed to these reasonings as their top reason for tuning out. 21.8%, meanwhile, cited “too many similar messages,” and 18.8% said that jargon-filled language is a top reason they ignore a healthcare message.

"Healthcare organizations have spent years measuring engagement by how many messages go out, not by whether any of them land," Lirio’s CEO Marten den Haring, Ph.D., said in a press release. "This data shows patients are already willing to act. Every irrelevant message decreases patient trust and attention, which health systems and plans need most as they head into open enrollment and year-end quality deadlines. The organizations that treat relevance as a performance metric will be the ones who create lasting relationships with their patients."

To his point, Lirio’s survey spanned age demographics, but across each age group, “personalization” was the most requested improvement to healthcare communications. Nearly half of respondents overall (47.9%) rated “more personalized, better-timed” communications as an important factor for keeping them engaged in their healthcare. 

To put it another way, patients feel that “the system is talking at them instead of to them,” Lirio’s chief behavioral officer Amy Bucher, Ph.D., added in the release. 

"The instinct in healthcare has long been to solve engagement with more outreach - more emails, more reminders, more portals. This data shows that volume is not the problem,” Bucher said. “What is missing is relevance—content and timing designed for where a specific patient is in their own health journey, rather than a single message broadcast to an entire population."

And although patients acknowledge that the responsibility for their own engagement largely falls on them themselves, as shown by 59.7% of those surveyed saying that they personally carry the greatest responsibility for staying engaged, navigating an onslaught of disconnected messaging can make pursuing and keeping up with care difficult. 

Often, patients have to put in the work to scour for the information they need across multiple platforms such as portals, websites and mail, which requires effort to piece together and act on the information. 71.6% of consumers report having to search “multiple places” for healthcare information, Lirio found, with 27.4% doing this “often or always.” 

According to Bucher, health organizations that can successfully communicate with patients will be the ones that lean on “behavioral data to determine the right message, the right channel and the right moment for each individual patient,” she continued. 

Lirio’s answer to this is its “Precision Nudging” platform, which merges behavioral science and AI to develop and deploy “hyper-personalized” messages at scale. There’s still plenty of room for healthcare systems to integrate technology and AI such as Lirio’s for patient engagement, as a January survey from Lirio and Sage Growth Partners found that just 5% of respondents reported being very satisfied with their technology capabilities to support medication adherence and 10% were satisfied with their tech tools when it comes to engaging patients about lifestyle modifications.